Improve Unit Testing with Visual C++ Programming

Visual Studio comes with an interesting tool for unit testing as described in this blog about Writing Unit Tests in Visual Studio for Native C++, but this solution had the following disadvantages due to using C++\CLI:

  • Intellisense not supported for C++\CLI.
  • Assert is designed for .Net languages , and using it for native C++ induce using some workarounds like:Assert for string,Assert::IsNullPointer.
  • nullptr exist both in C++0x and CLI and concerning test for C++0x code we have to use __nullptr instead.
  • Many developers don't understand why they have to use C++\CLI to test native C++.

This testing tool is very elegant; it can easily be plugged into Team Foundation Server TFS), so don't be discouraged by the disadvantages described.

There's a simple solution to the disadvantages, with few changes, that resolve these issues. To explain this solution let's change the following test class.

using namespace System::Text;
using namespace System::Collections::Generic;
using namespace Microsoft::VisualStudio::TestTools::UnitTesting;
namespace TestProject1
{
   [TestClass]
    public ref class UnitTest1
    {
      public:
        [TestMethod]
        void TestMethod1()
        {
           //some test code
        }
    };
}

The most feedback about this code is the use of C++\CLI instead of native C++. The goal is to implement an alternative solution to the one proposed by Visual Studio. For that, let's do the following steps:

Step1: Create a Native Class for Test

The best aproach to test native code is to use a native test class like any other existing test unit framework (CppUnit,googleTest,...)

Let's create our native test class:

NativeTest.h

class NativeUnitTest1
{
   Public:
      void TestMethod1();
}

NativeTest.cpp

#include "nativetest.h"
void NativeUnitTest1::TestMethod1(){
//Native test code
}

We have to change the "Common Language Support" property to "No Common language rutime support." I n this case the intellisense works perfectly , and all test code is written with native C++.

Step2 : Create NativeAssert Class to Encapsulate Managed Assert Class

For test methods we need to use Assert methods. To avoid the drawbacks of using the managed Assert class, and facilitate using this class for native code, let's create a native class that encapsulates the managed one.

NativeAssert.h file:

class NativeAssert
{
   public:
      static void AreEqual(int a,int b);
      static void AreEqual(std::string a,std::string b);
};

NativeAssert.cpp file:

using namespace Microsoft::VisualStudio::TestTools::UnitTesting;
#include "NativeAssert.h"
void  NativeAssert::AreEqual(int a,int b)
{
    Assert::AreEqual(a,b);
}
void  NativeAssert::AreEqual(std::string a,std::string b)
{
    Assert::AreEqual<System::String^>(gcnew System::String(a.c_str()), gcnew System::String(b.c_str()));
}

Of course, all assert methods needed must be added to this class; this class will be developed one time and used by all test cases.

Step3 : Use NariveAssert in the Native Test Methods

void NativeUnitTest1::TestMethod1(){
    //some code
    NativeAssert("test",p->name());
}

To improve the syntax we can add this define:

#define NativeAssert Assert

So the code will be:

void NativeUnitTest1::TestMethod1(){
    //some code
    Assert("test",p->name());
}

Step4: Integrate the Native Test Class into C++\CLI

Until now the goal has been to develop native test classes to avoid all of the drawbacks described before. In this last step, we have to integrate it to C++\CLI, and finally this CLI class will be just a wrapper to adapt the test class to the existing testing engine.

#include "nativetest.h"
using namespace System;
using namespace System::Text;
using namespace System::Collections::Generic;
using namespace Microsoft::VisualStudio::TestTools::UnitTesting;
namespace TestProject1
{
[TestClass]
public ref class UnitTest1
{
     public:
     [TestInitialize]
     void Initialize()
     {
        m_pTest=new NativeUnitTest1 ();
     }
     [TestCleanup]
     void Cleanup()
     {
         delete m_pTest;
     }
     [TestMethod]
     void TestMethod1()
     {
        m_pTest->test1();
     }
     NativeUnitTest1* m_pTest;
    };
}

The advantage of using this technique is that it resolves all problems related to creating a unit test for native C++ classes with few changes.



About the Author

Issam Lahlali

Product Manager of CppDepend. MCSD and MCSD.net certified.

Related Articles

Comments

  • good

    Posted by ghazanfar381 on 07/25/2011 05:02pm

    good article. http://solutionsdealer.net

    Reply
Leave a Comment
  • Your email address will not be published. All fields are required.

Top White Papers and Webcasts

  • Entire organizations suffer when their networks can't keep up and new opportunities are put on hold. Waiting on service providers isn't good business. In these examples, learn how to simplify network management so that your organization can better manage costs, adapt quickly to business demands, and seize market opportunities when they arise.

  • Microsoft® Office 365 is a top choice for enterprises that want a cloud–based suite of productivity collaboration applications. With Office 365, you get access to Microsoft™ Office solutions practically anytime, anywhere, on virtually any device. It's a great option for current Microsoft users who can now build on their experience with Microsoft™ solutions while enjoying the flexibility of a cloud-based delivery. But even organizations with no previous investment in Microsoft will find that …

Most Popular Programming Stories

More for Developers

RSS Feeds

Thanks for your registration, follow us on our social networks to keep up-to-date