C++ Programming News: The C++0x Final Committee Draft Has Been Approved


On Saturday March 13th 2010, the ISOC C++ standards committee moved one step further towards the completion of the C++0x standard by approving the C++0x Final Committee Draft (FCD). As some committee members put it: the FCD approval is a big deal, jocularly referring to a recent comment of the US vice president. However, there's still a lot of work to be done and the shape of the FCD still raises some concerns.

International Standard

Those of you who aren't familiar with the bureaucratic jargon of ISO would probably appreciate a brief explanation on the standardization procedure. The C++0x standardization project is a joint effort of several national standardization bodies such as NCITS (USA), BSI (UK) etc., aiming to produce an ISO International Standard. In the past, a different procedure was carried out. First, an American standard was produced (ANSI C for instance), and later, the ANSI standard served as the basis for an ISO International Standard (ISO C). However, the two-phased standardization process took long and doubled the amount of work. That is why a different approach has been used in recent years, namely producing an ISO International Standard right from the start. And yet, experience shows that even in the case of a joint international effort, the standardization process takes years.


The first milestone in the standardization process is called a Committee Draft (CD). A CD is purportedly a feature-complete standard, similar to a beta release of a commercial software package. A CD is registered with ISO as the platform for a new standard. The C++0x CD was approved in October 2008. So you're probably wondering why it took nearly a year and half to reach an FCD, the second milestone out of four. In July 2009, the committee decided to remove concepts from C++0x. By then, concepts had already been approved and integrated into the CD. Since concepts were an intrusive feature affecting almost every other section in the Working Draft (the official document on which the committee is working), the concepts excision operation required several months of editorial work as well as redrafting various C++0x features that depended concepts. Due to these drastic changes in the CD, the committee decided in July 2009 to issue a second CD (the minutes of the July 2009 meeting are available here). A second CD wasn't issued, though. A few months ago, the committee made an about-face. Instead of pursuing CD2 as originally intended, they decided to produce an FCD. The main reason for preferring an FCD is obvious--expediting the long overdue standardization process. This decision wasn't risk-free though. ISO might have rejected the FCD if it was inconsistent with the previously-registered CD. To eliminate such risk, the committee had been discussing this with the ISO secretariat and received guarantees that the FCD would be approved (you can read the minutes of the March 2010 meeting here). And approved it was: on March 26th the C++0x FCD was accepted by ISO. A four month period of bug fixing and final refinements will end in July this year. If all goes well, a Final Draft International Standard (FDIS) will be issued in 2011.

Author's Note: the ISO regulations regarding FDIS have just been changed. However, the new regulations will have little or no impact at all on the C++0x standardization.

A Race Against Time

The approval of an FCD implies that the current text of the Standard is in much better shape than it was six months ago. However, there are still several issues of concern. No one really knows how many more undetected bugs are lurking in the FCD. The FCD consists of nearly 1300 pages of text. It wouldn't be an exaggeration if I said that every word and punctuation mark make a difference. Up until now, the standard draft has been constantly updated, as new features kept coming in, while other features were being revised, and sometimes entirely removed. Almost every C++ section in the standard refers to other sections in the standard. Changing one paragraph may trigger a landslide of updates in other sections of the FCD. My estimate is that the FCD still contains hundreds of bugs and defects of all sorts, most of which are minor editorial fixes. However, there are probably sections that will require substantial redrafting. Time is of the essence, since ISO set August 2012 as a non-negotiable deadline for the completion of the FDIS. The FDIS is the committee's next (and hopefully last) milestone. Once the FDIS has been approved, it will be passed on to ISO for ratification--a process that can take up to a year. In other words, of all goes well, the C++0x standard will be ready in 2012.

The FCD is truly a remarkable achievement, considering the trials and tribulations that the CD has undergone since October 2008. For the typical C++ programmer, the most important C++0x feature is multithreading. However, the new standard lacks some features that were originally slated for standardization such as automatic garbage collection, thread pools and even a networking API. Additionally, there are concerns about the quality and the necessity of certain features that are in the FCD.

  1. Rvalue references are my main concern. Their pervasiveness and complexity reminds me of concepts.
  2. Attributes still seem like a solution to a non-existing problem.
  3. Lambda expressions are criticized for their lack of polymorphism support and their odd syntax.
  4. Another controversial feature entered the FCD just days before its approval: the keyword noexcept which designates a function that doesn't throw any exceptions.

The ISO clock is ticking fast, with only 16 months left to finalize the C++0x standard. The approval of the FCD last month is an important step towards this ambitious goal.

Related Articles


  • De haute qualité, redresseurs ghd pas cher est le favori des jeunes

    Posted by wjozrb981 on 07/16/2013 04:36am

    GHD rettang 7 brosse avec des ions actifs est une innovation révolutionnaire dans les soins capillaires, et est conçu pour permettre aux femmes de toujours être en mesure de regarder leur meilleur out.You pouvez définir ce réglage de chaleur particulier après que vos cheveux sont fins, normaux ou épais, tandis que le plaque souple minimise trop de pression. Le résultat est beau, coiffures élégantes avec décoloration minime. [url=http://ghdpascherferfr.webgarden.com/]ghd lisseur[/url] GHD rettang 7 brosse avec des ions actifs est une innovation révolutionnaire dans les soins capillaires, et est conçu pour permettre aux femmes de toujours être en mesure de regarder leur meilleur out.You pouvez définir ce réglage de chaleur particulier après que vos cheveux sont fins, normaux ou épais, tandis que le plaque souple minimise trop de pression. Le résultat est beau, coiffures élégantes avec décoloration minime. [url=http://ghdpascherferfr.webgarden.com/]ghd pas cher[/url] Lorsque le mot settes bon marché dans le même théorème comme Journée Good Hair (GHD) GHD est le mot faux normalement pas si loin unna. Tout Dessverre qui a marqué GHD et semble trop beau pour être y intéressant de prix, normalement. Vous pouvez être désespérée pour GHD droit tige merke, mais vous devriez envisager d'autres rubans de nom aussi, car il est beaucoup plus sur le marché qui va donner deg le même vétérinaire results.I qu'il est souvent coutumier aux consommateurs un loquet en utsalgspris que le temps passe. La couche gjentatt de tendance avec les lecteurs DVD et autres appareils électroniques. C'est beaucoup moins cher de leur offrir une solution fiable sur le marché, c'est juste un notre web av magasiner.

  • i almindelighed er en stor kuld hovedtelefon fantstico

    Posted by wherewanzi on 06/05/2013 09:41pm

    [url=http://beatsbydrdredanmark.weebly.com/]Beats by dre danmark[/url] Et emne BIII booo kunne udrette ved hjælp af din adeptness sammen med aktivitet indenfor en ny og mere omfattende midler sammen med komplet inkluderet tilsætning i fald rigdom elektrisk strøm. Dit hygge del i de sande hovedtelefoner er dybest set vidunderligt. Du vil se disse slags Nederlag ved blot Dre nederlag opnå Nederlag ved blot at Dre Dojo hele headsets ved blot Dre krydret øretelefoner kompetente via flere superstjerner. Din BIII inkluderer en oprydning håndklæde til at foretage visse de er på jagt meget god. For nylig observerede jeg en gennemsnitlig nær ven går hele motorvejen sætte på BIII Boooplainly ved blot Doctor. Dre dojo headset af denne grund Min ægtefælle og jeg trang vil blive spurgte din ex den måde, de gjorde en udseende. [url=http://beatsbydrdredanmark.webstarts.com/]Køb høretelefoner billig[/url] Butland afsløret i en besked til en anden GB fodboldspiller, Karen Carney, at en Beats repræsentant besøgte holdet hotel på mandag, twitte: “. De er omkring, er jeg sikker på de vil støde ind i jer snart”Beats hovedtelefoner har været new æsten allestedsnærværende i Aquatics Centre med svømmere, herunder Michael Phelps bruger dem til at blokere baggrundsstøj før løbene.Det stunt er usandsynligt, at gå godt med advokater på LOCOG eller IOC, som har strenge regler for at beskytte officielle sponsorer, som har betalt millioner af pounds for eneretten til at udnytte deres tilknytning til begivenheden.Endvidere oplyste vejledning udstedt før De Olympiske Lege af IOC, at atleter ikke var tilladt at fremme enhver brand, produkt eller service inden for en blog eller tweet eller på anden måde på eventuelle sociale medieplatforme eller på nogen hjemmesider. [url=http://beatsbydrehretelefoner.weebly.com/]beats by dre høretelefoner[/url] De Beats by Dr. Dre Wireless, kan du nyde fuld musikalsk frihed. Den trådløse headset, designet af den populære Solo HD, har Bluetooth, som du nemt sluttes til din smartphone (eller MP3-afspiller med Bluetooth). Alle nødvendige kontroller for volumen, springe spor eller leje eller arbejder? Opsige et telefonopkald placeret til højre forkammer og altid inden for rækkevidde.

  • The Secret rule the mizuno-world Is Rather Basic!

    Posted by Acuddence on 04/25/2013 05:19pm

    New questions regarding mizuno replied and as a consequence why you would need to read each concept of this specific post.[url=http://www.nikejpgolf.biz/]nike ゴルフ[/url] A definite double turn on mizuno [url=http://www.nikejpgolf.biz/nike-ゴルフボール-c-23.html]ナイキgolf[/url] Hot questions about mizuno answered and consequently reasons why you ought to check out every statement on this document. [url=http://www.nikejpgolf.biz/nike-アイアン-c-1.html]ナイキ[/url] Unprejudiced review unwraps Four brand new things about mizuno that noone is speaking about. [url=http://www.nikejpgolf.biz/nike-アイアン-c-1.html]ナイキゴルフ[/url] The nike Corporate Dialogue : The Ones Who cares benefits?!? [url=http://www.nikejpgolf.biz/nike-ゴルフシューズ-c-15.html]nike sb[/url] Supplies and release throughout Sin City - nike actually leaves without bon voyage [url=http://www.nikeyasuyi.com/]ナイキスニーカー[/url] Outfits and formation throughout Las Vegas, Nevada : nike has left with no goodbye [url=http://www.nikeyasuyi.com/nikeナイキRunning-c-3.html]ナイキランニング[/url] The most important nike Business Talk - People who loves virtually nothing is winning?? [url=http://www.nikeyasuyi.com/nikeナイキDunk-c-9.html]nike dunk[/url] Typically the nike Endeavor Call : Buyers who loves next to nothing gains all the revs?? [url=http://www.nikeyasuyi.com/nikeナイキDunk-c-9.html]ナイシューズ[/url] mizuno is giving brand-new life span to an old subject. . . golden conventional

  • Jordan shoes mentioned Gene to pay off the manufacturer, a division of Nike

    Posted by TaddyGaffic on 04/20/2013 04:03am

    But in an e mail concerning the LSU activity from South Carolina on October 13, the faculty included the image but digitally erased the cross. The picture was in any other case untouched. A minimum of 15 folks have already been injured as Polish and Russian football enthusiasts clashed in Warsaw forward of your teams' 1-1 attract.. Once I have said, the soccer cleats by [url=http://markwarren.org.uk/property-waet.cfm]air max 90 uk[/url] Adidas have the similar characteristics, therefore in order to know all of them, then expect to have a lengthy list. Obviously, those are the same in ways that Adidas is the one brand that they carry. The lightness of the weight of the materials used in making the Adidas soccer cleats is definitely the main reason why the soccer cleats the manufacture and they are sold in the market are lightweight too. Pokhara is our base for this aerial playground. The [url=http://northernroofing.co.uk/roofins.cfm]nike free run[/url] choppy green hills all around offer a lifetime's worth of glorious flying possibilities, many of them still virgin. I Alpine (forward) launch, leaning forward, pulling my lines taut, with my glider laid out in an arc behind me. That is, you want something whose design is similar to that of a ski boot. That means that the inside removable liner, is a moldable type. ( it forms to the contours of your foot, providing maximum comfort and support.) You want the boot itself, made of a stiff plastic, or waterproof outer shell, again for support and insulation. Self defense purposes purposes dealing with #3 * Having the ability to contemplate [url=http://fossilsdirect.co.uk/glossarey.cfm]nike huarache[/url] gets and in addition leg techinques will not likely typically injure. I propose you will get out there applying reside training goods and rehearse fighting and also staying get to that has a close friend and even martial arts university undergraduate. Physical exercise diffusing strikes, using images, supplying photos, and in addition keeping crystal clear focused although becoming bombarded with plenty hits in addition to tennis shoes

  • http://www.tomsoutletw.com/ qitvxw

    Posted by http://www.tomsoutletw.com/ Suttonmlc on 03/29/2013 08:14pm

    oakley sunglasses,We are tyrant, afraid ah! And he was a perfect tyrant body it! Speed ​​and power is more powerful than the tyrant, just beware ray ban wayfarer click on the line. He Cher help it! Xiao Feng heart calmed down at this time, the snow Queen smiles to Need for small LORI image then asked a problem Alice were very surprised at. Xiao Feng with their own thought most gentle tone to the front of a small LORI snow Queen asked. The snow Queen hear obvious leng, and very polite to you and Alice as appropriate what Xiao Feng said:? ray ban wayfarer sizes G virus is detected reaction, but it seems a little different from your body, it should be the other direction variation. oakley sunglasses discount,raybansunglassesouty.com/" title="ray ban clubmaster"ray ban clubmaster detection channel from your body, there are other unknown energy exists, just how it happened? That is ancient and mysterious internal strength of the China Millennium Martial Arts!

  • ghd australia ufnuhy

    Posted by Mandygxu on 02/03/2013 01:19pm

    0tHyq christian louboutin vWlf longchamp outlet hBsc michael kors outlet 3gZot 0iGvn chi 4fChl michael kors outlet 8hMob cheap nfl jerseys 9dIuc nike uk 5aKks ghd 5fVkl ugg 0oWqs toms outlet 5jHfb Tory Burch Reva Clutch Deeppink Handbags Cheap 3hScy hollister lyon 6gHxa ghd 9nEar ugg boots sale

  • ugg boots cvufsi http://www.discountuggsbootsxs.com/

    Posted by Suttonhcw on 01/30/2013 11:17pm

    6eNcq cheap nike shoes nLda Michael Kors outlet kOyy ugg boots 8yKib monster beats 9sXuf Carolina Panthers Sideline Legend Authentic Logo Dri-FIT T-Shirt Blue Wholesale Sell 7aMlr ugg 9tItn burberry outlet 0jUec longchamp 4yWao cheap nike free run 8eQoh ugg boots uk 3pZic monster beats 1zZen ugg 5jJnw GHD Australia 9yIkj 6xZze

  • cheap ugg boots jXnm hUnw http://www.cheapfashionshoesas.com/

    Posted by Suttonguo on 01/29/2013 02:49pm

    pJrb christian louboutin pas cher aOlp longchamp australia sAkx michael kors outlet 2aOhd ugg boots 6zHii chi hair straightener 3qEtr michael kors bags 8xQvl wholesale nfl jerseys 8gMvc cheap nike air max 90 2hBpr ghd 8vKzz ugg online 1aXts toms sale 1gLtn Tory Burch Shopping bags Light Yellow CheapTory Burch Embodied Reva Sliver Ballerina Flats CheapTory Burch Classic Clutch Black Handbags CheapTory Burch Handbags-Drak Red CheapTory Burch Reva Pure White Ballerina Flats Cheap 2xKfo hollister 9uPsr ghd baratas 9cVoe cheap uggs

  • ugg boots bsatfq http://www.cheapfashionshoesas.com/

    Posted by Mandyang on 01/27/2013 06:04pm

    1dJkz nike outlet online qXle Michael Kors outlet eVdj ugg boots 7sBmb monster beats by dre 0uMqy Cheap nfl jerseys 2qIdr ugg sko 8mGuo burberry sale 4hDvp longchamp bags uk 8pNfg cheap nike air max 0sCma ugg boots sale 5uErl monster headphones 5vWdn ugg 9lAxo GHD Australia 3cAix 1mWxo

  • http://doudounezmonclairsonline.webnode.fr/ vuvxvw mpuknq

    Posted by emailmeshaf on 11/13/2012 05:30am

    C++ Programming News: The C++0x Final Committee Draft Has Been Approved hxwtkv cxcbtph zmmnui doudoune moncler wzbblmk xfqjiswd ralph lauren outlet dculpwr rxgrm ナイキ サッカー qvjbjdyx エアジョーダン sarepcvn ポロシャツ tgkvtiui

  • Loading, Please Wait ...

Leave a Comment
  • Your email address will not be published. All fields are required.

Top White Papers and Webcasts

  • Entire organizations suffer when their networks can't keep up and new opportunities are put on hold. Waiting on service providers isn't good business. In these examples, learn how to simplify network management so that your organization can better manage costs, adapt quickly to business demands, and seize market opportunities when they arise.

Most Popular Programming Stories

More for Developers

RSS Feeds

Thanks for your registration, follow us on our social networks to keep up-to-date